Viewed – 16 December 2014 Cinema
Although with mixed feelings over this trilogy compared to the seminal masterworks of The Lord of the Rings, I was still optimistic walking into this final entry in director Peter Jackson’s fleshed out (and fleshed out) adaptation of J R R Tolkien’s classic novel. We join Bilbo and his merry band of Dwarves, headed by Thorin Oakenshield (Richard Armitage) housed up in the misty mountain following resident dragon Smaug having broke free and now laying siege to the nearby city of Lake Town. With riches beyond compare and the search for the Arkenstone underway, Thorin has become corrupted by the greed and lust to take his place as King, and only Bilbo has the power to help having stolen the stone in case it made the dwarf leader even worse. Meanwhile with the mountain now dragon-free, armies begin to approach for their share of the gold, and war looms.
Immediately this is a more dramatic and action-packed entry in the middle earth cannon and things are kicking off pretty much from the start, with the lead up to conflict pretty tense. However the corruption of Thorin and the Dwarves hanging around the mountain is a tad drawn out and I was eager for something to happen – and oh, did it! A massive, immense battle with legions upon legions of elves, orks, humans and dwarves all fighting … yet it was also pretty difficult to care all that much when it seemed like everyone was just out for a bigger piece of the pie – battle for middle earth (or helm’s deep for that matter) this was not. So then I was beginning to really find the dwarves annoying and wishing they’d never gone on their fabled journey, pissed off a dragon, causing countless deaths as a result. The whole quest as I’ve said before just not really seeming as necessary as what we see in LOTR. Are we really meant to care? No, and not even the director does it seems when the much sort after Arkenstone gets forgotten about entirely in the final act (but will no doubt re-surface in the extended edition…).
That being said this was still a treat for CGI fans and does boast excellent fight sequences (the showdown between Thorin and the Ork baddie especially) and good turns from Evangeline Lilly as Tauriel and Sir Ian McKellen as the always excellent Gandalf. Martin Freeman’s Bilbo remains a bit tiresome however for the lead, lacking the personality or depth of the likes of Elija Wood’s Frodo Baggins or Viggo Mortenson’s Aragorn. As a conclusion, this had plenty of energy and spectacle but lacked much of the wonder, diversity of locations and the sheer fantasy appeal of the other movies in the series … and for me is the weakest of the trilogy.
Verdict 3 /5